List: trawlers@lists.trawlering.com
From: Scott H.E. Welch
Re: T&T: Cradlepoint EVDO Router
Mon, Dec 1, 2008 3:07 PM
"Ron Rogers" writes:
> I
>have never wanted to return to those "challenges" and would never place
>complete reliance on a PC running a Microsoft OS - it's just too many lines
>of code. I know that you are not now doing that and the radar will have its
>own network, but the idea of having my radar imagery dependent upon a PC
>application scares me.
All reasonable. But the flip side is that a mass-market general-purpose PC
has lots of things going for it... starting with the 24" portrait-style
display.
>
>I'm too lazy to go back to the simplicity of Joshua Slocum, but I hear the
>work network and I get the Willies. My two Furuno chartplotters are connect
>via an Ethernet cross-over cable and that's as far as I go; except for NEMA
>0183 connections to GPS, VHF, and autopilot (all of which can run
>independently.)
Here's what I've done: my primary system consists of a clone PC (Windows XP)
running Nobeltec, with a Nobeltec black-box radar, Nobeltec solid-state
heading sensor, and a Furuno 600 depth sounder connected via NMEA. My
experience so far with this setup has been excellent.
My backup consists of a Garmin GPS, a Simrad radar, and an Interphase
sonar/sounder. These are completely stand-alone and are just fine if and when
the primary system fails. So far, I've only needed to use this once, when the
Nobeltec GPS went away to never-never land (a reboot solved the problem).
Finally, I have a laptop that I use for my EVDO routing. I also run a $39
puck GPS and a backup copy of Nobeltec on that machine, so I have backup maps
if I need them.
The autopilot is a Comnav 1001, fed via NMEA from Nobeltec and driving a 24
volt reversing hydraulic pumpset. It's powered by the 24 volt house bank.
There are two obvious points of failure with this system: the autopilot and
the steering ram. I carry a rebuild for the latter, and this summer I will be
installing a second Comnav autopilot and pumpset. This will not be networked,
but will be completely stand-alone. It will be powered from the 24 volt start
bank.
By the way, all of the power for the navigation instruments and lights goes
through an two-way selector, allowing me to draw power either from the 12
volt house bank or from the 12 volt genset start bank. The only exceptions to
this are the autopilot and SSB, which require 24 volts.
Scott Welch
FirstClass Product Manager
www.firstclass.com
"Things turn out best for people who make the best of the way things turn
out." - John Wooden