List: trawlers@lists.trawlering.com
From: Scott H.E. Welch
Re: T&T: USCG too-late esponse
Mon, Jun 16, 2008 4:31 PM
>Bottom line: despite the CPR-givers statement early on that there was foam
>from the mouth and blood from the nose and no vital signs, it took ONE HOUR
>for the helo to arrive. We were incredulous that it could take so long.
You know, further to my previous post about the North West Passage...
I hate to be heretical, but one hour seems pretty fast to me. In fact, that
they came at all seems pretty fabulous. When you are out on the water, you
really have to be prepared to deal with the situation on your own. It might
sound harsh, but death by misadventure is a harsh thing. We don't have the
resources to save every single person who does something stupid. Yes, it
would be fabulous if we had somebody there to help us every time we ****ed
up, but we can't always have that.
Perhaps there is another way we could approach this, and that's to ask
"What's the moral of this story"? I hate to sound like Mike, always harping
about this, but the best lessons you are going to learn are by observing
someone else's mistakes.
Here are a few observations, right off the top of my head:
1) First dive after certification? Let's do it off the dock instead of from a
boat. And even if it's not at the dock, should we really be 38 (!!!) miles
out?
2) Five guys in the water? Odd numbers are bad. Let's take it two at a time,
and have a buddy right beside the newbie. Also, 5 guys in the water meant
that the boat operator could not pick the newbie up because he was afraid of
hitting the other guys.
3) Adult male taken Vital Signs Absent and not breathing from warm water?
With foam from the mouth and blood from the nose? Probably already gone. A
copter's not going to help.
So what are the lessons?
1) Do a thorough risk analysis of the situation before you set off. If you
might need help, stay close to where the help is.
2) If you have a new diver, only let the new diver and his buddy into the
water (and make sure the buddy is experienced).
3) Keep a line on the newbie's wrist for the first few dives, so he can get
back to the boat easily. In my time up north, we did over 1000 under-ice
dives without a single incident, and that's partially because on every single
one of those dives the diver was tethered and there was a human tending the
line.
4) Make sure that every diver reads "Shadow Divers" by Robert Kurson.
Especially the part where the divers die. Just because you can get certified
in a few hours doesn't mean that it's not dangerous.
Just my two cents.
And by the way, don't you find it interesting that you never hear people
proposing higher taxes to pay for increased Coast Guard coverage?
Scott Welch
FirstClass Product Manager
www.firstclass.com
Those who make no mistakes rarely make anything.