List: trawlers@lists.trawlering.com
From: Faure, Marin
Top Choice Vessels less than 36'
Tue, Jun 5, 2007 5:23 PM
ularly the so-called "Taiwan Trawlers,"
is that American Marine achieved from the outset what many of the other
companies could not, and that was consistency of construction. Other
trawlers have design features that some people prefer over Grand Banks,
and in some cases certain aspects of their construction may be better,
or at least equal to, Grand Banks.
But where the Taiwan Trawlers fell down was in the consistency of their
construction. When we entered the market for a trawler back in 1998,
one of the first things we learned about boats like CHBs, etc. was that
while one particular boat can be a real gem in terms of construction
quality and integrity, the next hull number up can be a disaster. The
reason for this, we were told, is the manner in which the Taiwan boats
are, or at least were, made. The parent yard molded the hull but then
the hulls were farmed out to small, family-owned boatyards for
completion. So the construction quality of the finished boat became
totally dependent on the construction and quality standards of the
little yard that completed the boat. For example some of them used
pieces of packing crates to provide stiffeners for fiberglass cabin
sides. It was a low-cost solution, but when this kind of wood gets wet
it rots out practically overnight. Other yards used quality, sealed
marine ply as cabin side stiffeners. Unfortunately, short of
disassembling the boat, there is no way to tell how a particular boat
was made. The hardware used by one yard was not always of the same
quality as the hardware used by another yard.
American Marine, with an already-established, consistent process of
making their wood boats in Kowloon, set up an even more consistent
manufacturing process for their fiberglass boats in Singapore from day
one. All the work on every boat was done in the American Marine
facility. The original molds were designed by Howard Abbey and for the
first year or so after the start of fiberglass production he oversaw the
construction of each hull. The processes he and others established were
followed consistently (and still are). Materials did not vary widely
from boat to boat. Hardware was standardized, and so on. The design
features and construction techniques of a GB are certainly open for
discussion as to whether or not someone likes them. But-- setting aside
owner neglect or abuse-- the one thing you can count on with a GB is
that no matter the year or the hull number, any one boat will be every
bit as good as all the rest of them. There are no "packing crate
specials" lurking out there to ruin someone's day...:-)
______________________________
C. Marin Faure
GB36-403 "La Perouse"
Bellingham, Washington