trawlers@lists.trawlering.com

TRAWLERS & TRAWLERING LIST

View all threads

Re: TWL: Refrigeration/cold plate question

T
thataway4@home.com
Fri, Jan 4, 2002 2:07 AM

Darby,
We have built three different installations using eutectic holding
plates.
They work very well and are very efficient.  Perhaps the most important
feature is that there is effective insulation (vs. the small amount in the
Norcold type of units).  There is also no heat generated near the box.  The
compressor is remotely installed.  We found that an hour or max two a day
sufficed when in the Pacific North West, and up to four hours a day in the
tropics where the ambient temperature was up to 100 degrees.

The first unit was using a Sanyo Auto Air-conditioning compressor with a
Sundur water cooled heat exchanger.  There was a single "Dole" galvanized
cold plate in the freezer unit, with a bleed over, and small fan operated by
a thermostat in the refer unit.  The outside insulation was 4" of closed
cell foam, including the lid.  The separation was between the refer and
freezer was 2" closed cell foam.  The interior was fiberglassed and gel
coated.

The second unit used a 3/4 hp 110 V air cooled  compressor only. This was
both water and air cooled. There was a 12 cu foot refer with front opening
doors and about 2" of foam insulation (this was already in the boat) The
door seals were doubled and a cam type of latch was utilized for a very
tight seal.  The freezer was also 12 cu feet--a chest type, top opening,
with 6" of foam insulation on the sides and 4" on the top.  Both of these
had two Eutectic plates made of SS.  The freezer plate was rated at 0
degrees and the refer plate was 25 degrees.

The third unit used a Techanutics water cooled compressor and dual system
plates for the engine driven portion.  I used a Flemming water and air
cooled. Compressor for the 110 volt circuit.  There was a thermostat which
shut off the compressor for both the 110 volt and engine units.  The two
plates were rated at 0 degrees and placed in the freezer (six cubic foot
freezer and refer).  There was a bleed over, with a small fan operated by a
thermostat in the 2" separator between the refer and freezer (this separator
was Formica over foam.  There was a top load on the freezer and a top load
and a low front door (for the bottom) on the refer.  There was about 4" of
foam all around the units.

When I was able to, I first laid down a heavy aluminum foil reflective
barrier, then a 12 mil poly prop membrane, and then the foam.  The inner
surfaces were covered with fiberglass, gelcoated on the inside.
There were no voids in the foam.

In the last unit I installed a 12 /110 volt norcold "L" shaped unit to give
refer at the dock side, when I was not on the boat to run the freezer unit.

Another self contained unit to consider is the Nova Kool.  This appears to
be a slightly better unit than the Norcold at comparable price.
Bob Austin,
30 foot single diesel aft cabin Carver
Pensacola, FL.

Darby, We have built three different installations using eutectic holding plates. They work very well and are very efficient. Perhaps the most important feature is that there is effective insulation (vs. the small amount in the Norcold type of units). There is also no heat generated near the box. The compressor is remotely installed. We found that an hour or max two a day sufficed when in the Pacific North West, and up to four hours a day in the tropics where the ambient temperature was up to 100 degrees. The first unit was using a Sanyo Auto Air-conditioning compressor with a Sundur water cooled heat exchanger. There was a single "Dole" galvanized cold plate in the freezer unit, with a bleed over, and small fan operated by a thermostat in the refer unit. The outside insulation was 4" of closed cell foam, including the lid. The separation was between the refer and freezer was 2" closed cell foam. The interior was fiberglassed and gel coated. The second unit used a 3/4 hp 110 V air cooled compressor only. This was both water and air cooled. There was a 12 cu foot refer with front opening doors and about 2" of foam insulation (this was already in the boat) The door seals were doubled and a cam type of latch was utilized for a very tight seal. The freezer was also 12 cu feet--a chest type, top opening, with 6" of foam insulation on the sides and 4" on the top. Both of these had two Eutectic plates made of SS. The freezer plate was rated at 0 degrees and the refer plate was 25 degrees. The third unit used a Techanutics water cooled compressor and dual system plates for the engine driven portion. I used a Flemming water and air cooled. Compressor for the 110 volt circuit. There was a thermostat which shut off the compressor for both the 110 volt and engine units. The two plates were rated at 0 degrees and placed in the freezer (six cubic foot freezer and refer). There was a bleed over, with a small fan operated by a thermostat in the 2" separator between the refer and freezer (this separator was Formica over foam. There was a top load on the freezer and a top load and a low front door (for the bottom) on the refer. There was about 4" of foam all around the units. When I was able to, I first laid down a heavy aluminum foil reflective barrier, then a 12 mil poly prop membrane, and then the foam. The inner surfaces were covered with fiberglass, gelcoated on the inside. There were no voids in the foam. In the last unit I installed a 12 /110 volt norcold "L" shaped unit to give refer at the dock side, when I was not on the boat to run the freezer unit. Another self contained unit to consider is the Nova Kool. This appears to be a slightly better unit than the Norcold at comparable price. Bob Austin, 30 foot single diesel aft cabin Carver Pensacola, FL.
W
windmist@email.msn.com
Fri, Jan 4, 2002 4:28 AM

There is a company that specializes in refrigeration that may be of
interest.  If you have refrigeration experience you could build your own
system rather cheaply using their components.  They have a web site
www.rparts.com.  I am using their parts for my project however I am using
experienced refrigeration people to put together a holding plate system.
Refrigeration still baffles me.  It makes no sense to me making cold from
heat.

Ron Nelson
Cascade 36 trawler (under construction)

There is a company that specializes in refrigeration that may be of interest. If you have refrigeration experience you could build your own system rather cheaply using their components. They have a web site www.rparts.com. I am using their parts for my project however I am using experienced refrigeration people to put together a holding plate system. Refrigeration still baffles me. It makes no sense to me making cold from heat. Ron Nelson Cascade 36 trawler (under construction)