great-loop@lists.trawlering.com

Cruising America's Great Loop and other inland routes

View all threads

Stabilizers on a Krogen (or similar) 42

FA
Frank Arndorfer
Sat, Jan 23, 2010 11:19 PM

No experience with a Krogen but we added stabilizers to our Grand Banks 46
(2004 model) before we departed on our 'extended' Loop trip in 2005. Your
guess-timate of $50K is just about right on. Since they weren't added at the
factory at time of build, there's a significant amount of hardware that will
need to be moved and reorganized in the engine room. It's no small task.

But the difference they'll make in the boat's behavior is simply amazing.

Since leaving the Great Lakes in September 2005 we've travelled
approximately 12,000mi, about 3/4 in open ocean. They transform potentially
nasty seas into mild-mannered.

We chose Naiads. They've been 100% trouble-free since installation.

Frank Arndorfer
414.254.1668
262.628.3575 (fax)
fmja10@yahoo.com

No experience with a Krogen but we added stabilizers to our Grand Banks 46 (2004 model) before we departed on our 'extended' Loop trip in 2005. Your guess-timate of $50K is just about right on. Since they weren't added at the factory at time of build, there's a significant amount of hardware that will need to be moved and reorganized in the engine room. It's no small task. But the difference they'll make in the boat's behavior is simply amazing. Since leaving the Great Lakes in September 2005 we've travelled approximately 12,000mi, about 3/4 in open ocean. They transform potentially nasty seas into mild-mannered. We chose Naiads. They've been 100% trouble-free since installation. Frank Arndorfer 414.254.1668 262.628.3575 (fax) fmja10@yahoo.com
RR
Ron Rogers
Sun, Jan 24, 2010 2:37 AM

My remarks are specific to the Krogen 42 which I considered buying and
bilge-crawled, but otherwise have only studied. I have a Willard 40 with
Naiad 252's. First, many Krogen 42's have cored hulls to include below the
waterline. Therefore, the bosses that will have to be installed on all hulls
will involve more labor and materials to remove the core in way of the
bosses and replace the core with fiberglass and plywood. The Krogen 42 has a
"basement" with easy access for the installation of stabilizers. $40,000 to
$50,000 is as good a guess as any. Having observed the boat which I
considered being put over on her beam ends by an inconsiderate
sportfisherman, I could not contemplate such a genuine full-displacement
hull without some form of stabilization. My Willard has both a heavily
ballasted keel and stabilizers.

There are less costly stabilization methods to include "rolling chocks."
They are worth a Google. A friend has them on his Willard 40 and says that
they work well. His were designed and installed by a Maryland yard on the
lower Eastern Shore. Paravanes, as used by some commercial trawlers and
minesweepers, are for the open sea and not the ICW. They too are cheaper
than active fin stabilizers, but add a top-hamper to the boat.

Ron Rogers

My remarks are specific to the Krogen 42 which I considered buying and bilge-crawled, but otherwise have only studied. I have a Willard 40 with Naiad 252's. First, many Krogen 42's have cored hulls to include below the waterline. Therefore, the bosses that will have to be installed on all hulls will involve more labor and materials to remove the core in way of the bosses and replace the core with fiberglass and plywood. The Krogen 42 has a "basement" with easy access for the installation of stabilizers. $40,000 to $50,000 is as good a guess as any. Having observed the boat which I considered being put over on her beam ends by an inconsiderate sportfisherman, I could not contemplate such a genuine full-displacement hull without some form of stabilization. My Willard has both a heavily ballasted keel and stabilizers. There are less costly stabilization methods to include "rolling chocks." They are worth a Google. A friend has them on his Willard 40 and says that they work well. His were designed and installed by a Maryland yard on the lower Eastern Shore. Paravanes, as used by some commercial trawlers and minesweepers, are for the open sea and not the ICW. They too are cheaper than active fin stabilizers, but add a top-hamper to the boat. Ron Rogers