trawlers@lists.trawlering.com

TRAWLERS & TRAWLERING LIST

View all threads

Monster Wave

DL
Dave Legrow
Sun, Jan 21, 2007 11:42 PM

It was a short clip of the M/V Explorer from January of
2005, south of the Alaskan island chain, when she was hit
by a 50 foot rogue wave, in 30 foot seas.  Far be it from
anyone on this list to be qualified to second guess the
officers on this ship.

BTW, she is currently sitting at anchor outside of Port
Everglades.

The other clips that are generally shown on YouTube are of
life as it happens in the real shipping world - that is why
there are so many clips of heavy weather.  Sometimes its
miserable, and sometimes you pray the ship holds together.
However, that is life - they rarely turn around because the
weather is bad.

The clips do give you an idea of some of the incredible
racking, hogging, and sagging stresses that the ships must
endure.  Thus at least you can gain a conceptual
understanding of why they occasionally break in two as they
get older.

Dave Legrow
(not on)T'III
Everyone is raving about the all-new Yahoo! Mail beta.
http://new.mail.yahoo.com

It was a short clip of the M/V Explorer from January of 2005, south of the Alaskan island chain, when she was hit by a 50 foot rogue wave, in 30 foot seas. Far be it from anyone on this list to be qualified to second guess the officers on this ship. BTW, she is currently sitting at anchor outside of Port Everglades. The other clips that are generally shown on YouTube are of life as it happens in the real shipping world - that is why there are so many clips of heavy weather. Sometimes its miserable, and sometimes you pray the ship holds together. However, that is life - they rarely turn around because the weather is bad. The clips do give you an idea of some of the incredible racking, hogging, and sagging stresses that the ships must endure. Thus at least you can gain a conceptual understanding of why they occasionally break in two as they get older. Dave Legrow (not on)T'III Everyone is raving about the all-new Yahoo! Mail beta. http://new.mail.yahoo.com
MM
Mike Maurice
Mon, Jan 22, 2007 12:08 AM

Since the subject has come up, it is well documented that in a seaway of
30 foot average waves the chances of a 50 footer is quite high. There is
a slight chance of one 90 feet high.
Issues such as this are not a private matter or entitled to be buried
under a rug. They are legitimate topics of debate and discussion.

Regards,
Mike

Since the subject has come up, it is well documented that in a seaway of 30 foot average waves the chances of a 50 footer is quite high. There is a slight chance of one 90 feet high. Issues such as this are not a private matter or entitled to be buried under a rug. They are legitimate topics of debate and discussion. Regards, Mike
AJ
Arild Jensen
Mon, Jan 22, 2007 2:01 AM

-----Original Message-----
From: Dave Legrow
The clips do give you an idea of some of the incredible
racking, hogging, and sagging stresses that the ships must
endure.  Thus at least you can gain a conceptual
understanding of why they occasionally break in two as they
get older.

Dave Legrow

REPLY
The scary part being its not only older ships that break up but relatively
new vessels.
Blame a trend in design to reduce scantling size to reduce cost of building.
Remember many yayrds quote price based on weight of hul material.

Translating this into the recreational boat market, same issue applies.
With cost of resin escalating in lock step with crude oil prices (feed
stock) al builders are being squeezed between agreed sales price from before
when contract was signed with reality of current prices in resin etc.

Demand for more fuel efficient hulls often means a need to reduce weight of
total boat.
This in turn leads to having to find ways to reduce weight in all aspects of
boat construction.
Scantling size, bulkhead construction, furnituer and interior layout al come
under scrutiny.

some companies look to resin infusion to save on material and most look to
building interiors from lighter materials ( read thinner).

Some builders are more sucessful than other. Carbon fiber reinforcement
looks attractiver in terms of lighter build for same strenght. However that
requires special techniques and each yard has to go through a learning
curve. Some builders send staff for training while others rely on in-house
self taught experiemnts.  Results vary.

If the big commercial ship yards can make mistakes resulting in relatively
new ships breaking up, so will the smaller individual builders. It becomes a
real challenge to assess the qualification of any builder/yard in terms of
being sucessful in applying new construction technology.

Just another aspect of boat building
regards
Arild

> -----Original Message----- > From: Dave Legrow > The clips do give you an idea of some of the incredible > racking, hogging, and sagging stresses that the ships must > endure. Thus at least you can gain a conceptual > understanding of why they occasionally break in two as they > get older. > > Dave Legrow REPLY The scary part being its not only older ships that break up but relatively new vessels. Blame a trend in design to reduce scantling size to reduce cost of building. Remember many yayrds quote price based on weight of hul material. Translating this into the recreational boat market, same issue applies. With cost of resin escalating in lock step with crude oil prices (feed stock) al builders are being squeezed between agreed sales price from before when contract was signed with reality of current prices in resin etc. Demand for more fuel efficient hulls often means a need to reduce weight of total boat. This in turn leads to having to find ways to reduce weight in all aspects of boat construction. Scantling size, bulkhead construction, furnituer and interior layout al come under scrutiny. some companies look to resin infusion to save on material and most look to building interiors from lighter materials ( read thinner). Some builders are more sucessful than other. Carbon fiber reinforcement looks attractiver in terms of lighter build for same strenght. However that requires special techniques and each yard has to go through a learning curve. Some builders send staff for training while others rely on in-house self taught experiemnts. Results vary. If the big commercial ship yards can make mistakes resulting in relatively new ships breaking up, so will the smaller individual builders. It becomes a real challenge to assess the qualification of any builder/yard in terms of being sucessful in applying new construction technology. Just another aspect of boat building regards Arild
MM
Mike Maurice
Mon, Jan 22, 2007 3:59 AM

Here are several more clips. All but one are pretty spectacular watching.
They are on my video  web page, but without comments, so far.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=szk83cONAqM

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qPYodT4jl04

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lgt-yqqz7oM

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UNaYjQG1S6w

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z2TXkmX--wc

Mike


Capt. Mike Maurice
Beaverton Oregon(Near Portland)

Here are several more clips. All but one are pretty spectacular watching. They are on my video web page, but without comments, so far. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=szk83cONAqM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qPYodT4jl04 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lgt-yqqz7oM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UNaYjQG1S6w http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z2TXkmX--wc Mike _____________________________________ Capt. Mike Maurice Beaverton Oregon(Near Portland)
RR
Ron Rogers
Mon, Jan 22, 2007 4:32 AM

Or you could buy a Willard 30 or 40 with a slippery, full-displacement hull
whose scantlings are battleship thick. Remember the posting about the new
Sea Ray on autopilot in the Houston shipping channel? Something went wrong
and she did a hard right at 15 to 19mph. The banks were mud and her hull
folded like an accordion leaving only the deck forward of the helm. A man on
the forward queen-sized bed was thrown against the midship bulkhead, but
wasn't badly injured. The boat was a total loss.

A Willard would have dented the mud. Buy quality.

Ron Rogers
whose Willard 40 is NOT
for sale.

----- Original Message -----
From: "Arild Jensen" elnav@telus.net

| The scary part being its not only older ships that break up but relatively
| new vessels.
| Blame a trend in design to reduce scantling size to reduce cost of
building.
| Remember many yayrds quote price based on weight of hul material.
|
| Translating this into the recreational boat market, same issue applies.
| With cost of resin escalating in lock step with crude oil prices (feed
| stock) al builders are being squeezed between agreed sales price from
before
| when contract was signed with reality of current prices in resin etc.
|
| Demand for more fuel efficient hulls often means a need to reduce weight
of
| total boat.
| This in turn leads to having to find ways to reduce weight in all aspects
of
| boat construction.
| Scantling size, bulkhead construction, furnituer and interior layout al
come
| under scrutiny. Some companies look to resin infusion to save on material
and most look to
| building interiors from lighter materials ( read thinner).

Or you could buy a Willard 30 or 40 with a slippery, full-displacement hull whose scantlings are battleship thick. Remember the posting about the new Sea Ray on autopilot in the Houston shipping channel? Something went wrong and she did a hard right at 15 to 19mph. The banks were mud and her hull folded like an accordion leaving only the deck forward of the helm. A man on the forward queen-sized bed was thrown against the midship bulkhead, but wasn't badly injured. The boat was a total loss. A Willard would have dented the mud. Buy quality. Ron Rogers whose Willard 40 is NOT for sale. ----- Original Message ----- From: "Arild Jensen" <elnav@telus.net> | The scary part being its not only older ships that break up but relatively | new vessels. | Blame a trend in design to reduce scantling size to reduce cost of building. | Remember many yayrds quote price based on weight of hul material. | | Translating this into the recreational boat market, same issue applies. | With cost of resin escalating in lock step with crude oil prices (feed | stock) al builders are being squeezed between agreed sales price from before | when contract was signed with reality of current prices in resin etc. | | Demand for more fuel efficient hulls often means a need to reduce weight of | total boat. | This in turn leads to having to find ways to reduce weight in all aspects of | boat construction. | Scantling size, bulkhead construction, furnituer and interior layout al come | under scrutiny. Some companies look to resin infusion to save on material and most look to | building interiors from lighter materials ( read thinner).
RR
Ron Rogers
Mon, Jan 22, 2007 5:06 AM

I went to the videos Mike suggested and the first was disturbing. A bunch of
casual idiots delivering what appears to be a superyacht. Their attitude
resulted in injuries to two crew members.

Then I went on to the second one called Marejada - fantastic. When I grow up
and win Powerball, I'm gonna buy one! This is a rescue/salvage ship of great
design and power. With a helicopter in overwatch, she's plowing directly
into significant head seas and just rising and falling to each one, busting
through without apparent loss of speed. I strongly recommend the videos by
MedlineIII as they are inspirational. He does one amazing thing. He
juxtaposes the tank tests of this magnificent vessel to her actually
performing the same actions at sea. She does even better in real life. It is
extraordinary. If she was coming to get me, I'd have every confidence she'd
make it out and back. Just watch this fellows videos while listening to the
beautiful music. Of course, she must have a helluva fuel bill! {;*D)

I'm going back to look at more of his videos and watch this magnificent
ship. She is either amazingly stable or has some honking stabilizers.

Thanks Mike,
Ron  Rogers

I went to the videos Mike suggested and the first was disturbing. A bunch of casual idiots delivering what appears to be a superyacht. Their attitude resulted in injuries to two crew members. Then I went on to the second one called Marejada - fantastic. When I grow up and win Powerball, I'm gonna buy one! This is a rescue/salvage ship of great design and power. With a helicopter in overwatch, she's plowing directly into significant head seas and just rising and falling to each one, busting through without apparent loss of speed. I strongly recommend the videos by MedlineIII as they are inspirational. He does one amazing thing. He juxtaposes the tank tests of this magnificent vessel to her actually performing the same actions at sea. She does even better in real life. It is extraordinary. If she was coming to get me, I'd have every confidence she'd make it out and back. Just watch this fellows videos while listening to the beautiful music. Of course, she must have a helluva fuel bill! {;*D) I'm going back to look at more of his videos and watch this magnificent ship. She is either amazingly stable or has some honking stabilizers. Thanks Mike, Ron Rogers
KD
Kirwood Dirby
Mon, Jan 22, 2007 2:08 PM

On 1/21/07, Dave Legrow dlegrow@yahoo.com wrote:
<snjip>

Far be it from
anyone on this list to be qualified to second guess the
officers on this ship.

as far as being qualified, I have no idea who is or is not qualified
to pilot that ship, I am not. However, EVERYONE should second guess
when someone else makes a mistake. Its how we get better. Ask
questions, make assumptions, then listen when someone qualified says
"yeah, thats true" or "no, you didnt think of this".

To sit quietly and say "I am not qualified to comment" is to not
learn. And on the other side of that coin... When I am the one making
the mistake, I dont mind "unqualified" people commenting, sometimes
theyh ave insights that are not tainted by being to close to the
topic.

--
PaulC
http://www.teampaulc.org/

On 1/21/07, Dave Legrow <dlegrow@yahoo.com> wrote: <snjip> > Far be it from > anyone on this list to be qualified to second guess the > officers on this ship. as far as being qualified, I have no idea who is or is not qualified to pilot that ship, I am not. However, EVERYONE should second guess when someone else makes a mistake. Its how we get better. Ask questions, make assumptions, then listen when someone qualified says "yeah, thats true" or "no, you didnt think of this". To sit quietly and say "I am not qualified to comment" is to not learn. And on the other side of that coin... When I am the one making the mistake, I dont mind "unqualified" people commenting, sometimes theyh ave insights that are not tainted by being to close to the topic. -- PaulC http://www.teampaulc.org/
RC
R C Smith Jr
Mon, Jan 22, 2007 3:40 PM

Latest issue of Boating mag has a primer on generators (p. 88). They claim 2
and 4 cylinder gensets vibrate more than 3 and 6 cylinders models.

I always thought a 3-cylinder was the shake-rattle-and-roll king. I am in
the market for an 8 to 10 KW genset and was avoiding the 3s. Have I been
operating in a fog of blissful ignorance...again?

Bob


Robert Calhoun Smith Jr
M/V MARY KATHRYN
Hatteras 58 LRC
The Jib Room, Marsh Harbour, Abaco, Bahamas

Latest issue of Boating mag has a primer on generators (p. 88). They claim 2 and 4 cylinder gensets vibrate more than 3 and 6 cylinders models. I always thought a 3-cylinder was the shake-rattle-and-roll king. I am in the market for an 8 to 10 KW genset and was avoiding the 3s. Have I been operating in a fog of blissful ignorance...again? Bob ________________ Robert Calhoun Smith Jr M/V MARY KATHRYN Hatteras 58 LRC The Jib Room, Marsh Harbour, Abaco, Bahamas
CH
Carl H. Martin
Tue, Jan 23, 2007 1:52 AM

These are amazing Mike.  The video of Mara changing out lighthouse keepers
blew me away.  It looks incredibly dangerous but appears to be normal
procedure.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gNZnM7qOmuI&mode=related&search=

Carl

These are amazing Mike. The video of Mara changing out lighthouse keepers blew me away. It looks incredibly dangerous but appears to be normal procedure. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gNZnM7qOmuI&mode=related&search= Carl
MM
Mike Maurice
Tue, Jan 23, 2007 2:04 AM

These are amazing Mike.  The video of Mara changing out lighthouse keepers
blew me away.  It looks incredibly dangerous but appears to be normal
procedure.

The lighthouses at Tillamook Rock and Tatoosh Island used similar
hoisting. I am sure there have been many others, including the one near
Crescent City CA.

Mike


Capt. Mike Maurice
Beaverton Oregon(Near Portland)

> These are amazing Mike. The video of Mara changing out lighthouse keepers > blew me away. It looks incredibly dangerous but appears to be normal > procedure. > The lighthouses at Tillamook Rock and Tatoosh Island used similar hoisting. I am sure there have been many others, including the one near Crescent City CA. Mike _____________________________________ Capt. Mike Maurice Beaverton Oregon(Near Portland)