trawlers@lists.trawlering.com

TRAWLERS & TRAWLERING LIST

View all threads

Re: T&T: VHF and antenna

DH
David H Sorenson
Wed, May 6, 2009 1:39 PM

Hi Ron, first, my experience in the past was in commercial FM broadcast
engineering (30 years ago). I have no experience in Ham radio. A PL-259
is essentially a "consumer grade" coaxial RF connector. Type N connectors
are more industrial grade. They have greater connectivity by their
inherent design and thus less signal loss.  I presume that is why they
are preferred by professional/industrial applications and hence Ham radio
people. (They are also more difficult to install on a coax than a
PL-259.)

David Sorenson
Duluth, MN

David, can you tell us why some HAMs substitute type "N" connectors
for type
PL-259? I assume it has something to do with efficiency/signal
loss.
However, I would think that the adapter would introduce loss.

If David Cooper is satisfied with the Uniden WHAM setup, that is a
strong
endorsement from a couple who live aboard and cruise extensively
and
regularly.

Ron Rogers


Compete with the big boys.  Click here to find products to benefit your business.
http://thirdpartyoffers.juno.com/TGL2141/fc/BLSrjpTI97yJnLNDcVY6GgkJ46AfovPPEg3WCLQG5xcfNi99PwC4bwNSjnC/

Hi Ron, first, my experience in the past was in commercial FM broadcast engineering (30 years ago). I have no experience in Ham radio. A PL-259 is essentially a "consumer grade" coaxial RF connector. Type N connectors are more industrial grade. They have greater connectivity by their inherent design and thus less signal loss. I presume that is why they are preferred by professional/industrial applications and hence Ham radio people. (They are also more difficult to install on a coax than a PL-259.) David Sorenson Duluth, MN > > David, can you tell us why some HAMs substitute type "N" connectors > for type > PL-259? I assume it has something to do with efficiency/signal > loss. > However, I would think that the adapter would introduce loss. > > If David Cooper is satisfied with the Uniden WHAM setup, that is a > strong > endorsement from a couple who live aboard and cruise extensively > and > regularly. > > Ron Rogers > > > ____________________________________________________________ Compete with the big boys. Click here to find products to benefit your business. http://thirdpartyoffers.juno.com/TGL2141/fc/BLSrjpTI97yJnLNDcVY6GgkJ46AfovPPEg3WCLQG5xcfNi99PwC4bwNSjnC/
EB
Ed Bruette
Wed, May 6, 2009 4:00 PM

Ron,

The PL-259 presents an impedance mismatch in the antenna system, hence the
signal loss.  The "N" connector does not.  Additionally the "N" connector is
much more WX resistant and when properly assembled will not allow water
intrusion.  The prudent installer will still provide external layers of
sealing for connectors that are exposed to the elements.

Ed, N7NVP
PT-38  "Makin' Do"
Poulsbo, WA

-----Original Message-----

Hi Ron, first, my experience in the past was in commercial FM broadcast
engineering (30 years ago). I have no experience in Ham radio. A PL-259 is
essentially a "consumer grade" coaxial RF connector. Type N connectors are
more industrial grade. They have greater connectivity by their inherent
design and thus less signal loss.  I presume that is why they are preferred
by professional/industrial applications and hence Ham radio people. (They
are also more difficult to install on a coax than a PL-259.)

David Sorenson
Duluth, MN

David, can you tell us why some HAMs substitute type "N" connectors
for type PL-259? I assume it has something to do with
efficiency/signal loss.

Ron Rogers

Ron, The PL-259 presents an impedance mismatch in the antenna system, hence the signal loss. The "N" connector does not. Additionally the "N" connector is much more WX resistant and when properly assembled will not allow water intrusion. The prudent installer will still provide external layers of sealing for connectors that are exposed to the elements. Ed, N7NVP PT-38 "Makin' Do" Poulsbo, WA -----Original Message----- Hi Ron, first, my experience in the past was in commercial FM broadcast engineering (30 years ago). I have no experience in Ham radio. A PL-259 is essentially a "consumer grade" coaxial RF connector. Type N connectors are more industrial grade. They have greater connectivity by their inherent design and thus less signal loss. I presume that is why they are preferred by professional/industrial applications and hence Ham radio people. (They are also more difficult to install on a coax than a PL-259.) David Sorenson Duluth, MN > > David, can you tell us why some HAMs substitute type "N" connectors > for type PL-259? I assume it has something to do with > efficiency/signal loss. > > Ron Rogers