passagemaking@lists.trawlering.com

Passagemaking Under Power List

View all threads

twin screws?

LB
Lorenzo Boelitz
Wed, Sep 16, 2009 11:41 AM

If you want to compare singles and twins purely on economics, take a look at what's done around the world by commercial operators trying to squeeze every nickel they can out of their boats in a competitive market. They pretty much all have single mains and single screws. That's not to say that twins aren't worth the extra money to the recreational boater.

If you want to compare singles and twins purely on economics, take a look at what's done around the world by commercial operators trying to squeeze every nickel they can out of their boats in a competitive market. They pretty much all have single mains and single screws. That's not to say that twins aren't worth the extra money to the recreational boater.
2
2elnav@netbistro.com
Wed, Sep 16, 2009 5:04 PM

----- Original Message -----
From: "Lorenzo Boelitz" lorenzo@backyards.biz
If you want to compare singles and twins purely on economics, take a look
at what's done around the world by commercial operators trying to squeeze
every nickel they can out of their boats in a competitive market. They
pretty much all have single mains and single screws. That's not to say that
twins aren't worth the extra money to the recreational boater.

REPLY
Great Lakes bulk carriers  have twin engines and single screw.  The
difference  in power needed to go upstream against a 4 knot current is
considerable.  The ore carrier I was on had  twin 10,000  HP engines.  A
gear box tied the two  to a common shaft. We needed both engines at full
power to go upstream but when in a lake or going downstrean  only one engine
sufficed.
Handling  and rudder action never varied  regardless of  using one or both.

Volvo did make a few of these but the idea never caught on in the North
American recreational market.

Cheers
Arild

----- Original Message ----- From: "Lorenzo Boelitz" <lorenzo@backyards.biz> If you want to compare singles and twins purely on economics, take a look at what's done around the world by commercial operators trying to squeeze every nickel they can out of their boats in a competitive market. They pretty much all have single mains and single screws. That's not to say that twins aren't worth the extra money to the recreational boater. REPLY Great Lakes bulk carriers have twin engines and single screw. The difference in power needed to go upstream against a 4 knot current is considerable. The ore carrier I was on had twin 10,000 HP engines. A gear box tied the two to a common shaft. We needed both engines at full power to go upstream but when in a lake or going downstrean only one engine sufficed. Handling and rudder action never varied regardless of using one or both. Volvo did make a few of these but the idea never caught on in the North American recreational market. Cheers Arild