trawlers@lists.trawlering.com

TRAWLERS & TRAWLERING LIST

View all threads

Echo charger on genset battery issue

CC
Candy Chapman and Gary Bell
Tue, Feb 26, 2008 8:06 AM

Should I not use the echo charger on the genset battery?

There should be no need to use an echo charger if the Northern Lights genset
also charges its own start battery.  Think about the battery in your car.  The
alternator output is sized and regulated to more than adequately replace the
amount of current drawn out of the battery when starting.  A properly balanced
system will run without a fuss for years -- and most often die of old age.  If
you have to use an outside charger on it something is broke.

Yes the echo charger will react badly to finding the genset's charge voltage
on the battery.  It seems as though you have correctly identified the reason
the ProSine needed resetting.  I had (and many others here did as well) lots
of trouble with my ProSine 2000 and with attempts to get repairs on them.  We
went all through that a couple of years ago on this list, and we still revisit
it from time to time.  Your unit may or may not share the propensities for
trouble that mine had.  There appears to be some hope that Xantrex fixed the
problem with the manufacturer.  I would definitely take the echo charger off
the genset start battery if the Northern Lights has a starter charging
circuit, for fear of damaging either the ProSine, the echo charger or even the
charging system on the Northern Lights. I also presume that the start battery
for the genset is not used for much else, and that it is a proper starting
design battery.

Gary Bell

Should I not use the echo charger on the genset battery? There should be no need to use an echo charger if the Northern Lights genset also charges its own start battery. Think about the battery in your car. The alternator output is sized and regulated to more than adequately replace the amount of current drawn out of the battery when starting. A properly balanced system will run without a fuss for years -- and most often die of old age. If you have to use an outside charger on it something is broke. Yes the echo charger will react badly to finding the genset's charge voltage on the battery. It seems as though you have correctly identified the reason the ProSine needed resetting. I had (and many others here did as well) lots of trouble with my ProSine 2000 and with attempts to get repairs on them. We went all through that a couple of years ago on this list, and we still revisit it from time to time. Your unit may or may not share the propensities for trouble that mine had. There appears to be some hope that Xantrex fixed the problem with the manufacturer. I would definitely take the echo charger off the genset start battery if the Northern Lights has a starter charging circuit, for fear of damaging either the ProSine, the echo charger or even the charging system on the Northern Lights. I also presume that the start battery for the genset is not used for much else, and that it is a proper starting design battery. Gary Bell