trawlers@lists.trawlering.com

TRAWLERS & TRAWLERING LIST

View all threads

Re: The Top Trawler of All Time

M
mikef@ciaccess.com
Sat, Jan 23, 1999 3:54 AM

Interesting post.  As I read it, though, there are two groups of candidates:
production boat models, and specific boats (Passagemaker, Salvation II,
Zopilote, etc.)

Why not make two lists?  One is a "wish list" -  listing boat models to lust
after, and the second list a "hall of fame" list for specific boats.

While we're making lists, how about assembling a list of passagemakers who
have circumnavigated?  Sort of a hero's list for the rest of us.  You could
keep it posted (with a photo of their vessel) on the web site.

I'll quit making work for you know, Georgs <g>.

Mike

"I love work.  I could watch it all day."  (anyone know who said this?)

-----Original Message-----
From: Georgs Kolesnikovs gxk@interlog.com
To: Trawler World List trawler-world-list@samurai.com
Date: January 22, 1999 4:50 PM
Subject: The Top Trawler of All Time

Drum roll!

Here are the results of your votes for TWList's Top 10 Trawlers of All
Time, based on posts to the List and email in my mailbox:

#1) Willard--the 30, 36 Vega and 40--has received the most mentions.

#2) Kadey-Krogen--especially the 48 series--also received many mentions.

#3) These two makes are quite a distance ahead of Grand Banks, with the 42
Classic garnering the most votes.

#4) Zopilote and especially Spirit of Zopilote are next, a tribute to the
Bruce Kessler-Steve Seaton collaboration.

#5) Arthur DeFever's designs, Alaskan 48 and DeFever 49, received the next
cluster of votes.

#6 through #8 equal votes) In alphabetical order:

--Marine Trader
--Nordhavn 46, with a special nod to Jim and Susy Sink of Salvation II
--Romsdal

#9 and 11 tied also) In alphabetical order:

--Nordic Tugs
--Passagemaker by Robert Beebe
--Rueben Trane and the Florida Bay Coasters designed by Jay Benford and
Great Harbour 37 designed by Louis Codega.

What an interesting selection! Wouldn't you love to have one of each at
your dock?

Of the above boats, if you could only have a single one, and price were not
a consideration, which one would you chose? Please cast your ballot for
only one boat by emailing me at mailto:news@trawlerworld.com. If you
mention more than one boat, you vote will not be counted.

Honorable mentions in the three weeks of polling were, in alphabetical
order, as follows:

--Albin
--Allweather 26
--Busted Flush
--Bylgia II, a 40-foot Dutch custom circumnavigator
--Californian 35 and 42
--CHB
--Columbia, ex Where Too, custom 60 by Bill Brees
--Dory 50
--Fales 32 Seeker
--Fleming 55
--Gulfstar 43 and 44
--Hatteras 48 LRC
--Hershine
--Kanter 57
--Mainship 34 and 350
--Modus 1500 LRC
--Monk 36
--Odessa, custom 52 by Ben Ostlund.

After the voting for the single one top trawler of all time is done, I'll
assemble all of this, with pictures, at Trawler World Online. Perhaps with
a ballot form so the trawler world at large can also make its selection of
the top 10 trawler of all time known.

As far as the List goes, next December we'll pick the TWList's Trawler of
the Decade from among only the boats introduced during the 1990s. That will
be cool way to wrap up the century, n'est-ce pas?

--Listmeister Georgs

Interesting post. As I read it, though, there are two groups of candidates: production boat models, and specific boats (Passagemaker, Salvation II, Zopilote, etc.) Why not make two lists? One is a "wish list" - listing boat models to lust after, and the second list a "hall of fame" list for specific boats. While we're making lists, how about assembling a list of passagemakers who have circumnavigated? Sort of a hero's list for the rest of us. You could keep it posted (with a photo of their vessel) on the web site. I'll quit making work for you know, Georgs <g>. Mike "I love work. I could watch it all day." (anyone know who said this?) -----Original Message----- From: Georgs Kolesnikovs <gxk@interlog.com> To: Trawler World List <trawler-world-list@samurai.com> Date: January 22, 1999 4:50 PM Subject: The Top Trawler of All Time >Drum roll! > >Here are the results of your votes for TWList's Top 10 Trawlers of All >Time, based on posts to the List and email in my mailbox: > >#1) Willard--the 30, 36 Vega and 40--has received the most mentions. > >#2) Kadey-Krogen--especially the 48 series--also received many mentions. > >#3) These two makes are quite a distance ahead of Grand Banks, with the 42 >Classic garnering the most votes. > >#4) Zopilote and especially Spirit of Zopilote are next, a tribute to the >Bruce Kessler-Steve Seaton collaboration. > >#5) Arthur DeFever's designs, Alaskan 48 and DeFever 49, received the next >cluster of votes. > >#6 through #8 equal votes) In alphabetical order: > >--Marine Trader >--Nordhavn 46, with a special nod to Jim and Susy Sink of Salvation II >--Romsdal > >#9 and 11 tied also) In alphabetical order: > >--Nordic Tugs >--Passagemaker by Robert Beebe >--Rueben Trane and the Florida Bay Coasters designed by Jay Benford and >Great Harbour 37 designed by Louis Codega. > >What an interesting selection! Wouldn't you love to have one of each at >your dock? > >Of the above boats, if you could only have a single one, and price were not >a consideration, which one would you chose? Please cast your ballot for >only one boat by emailing me at <mailto:news@trawlerworld.com>. If you >mention more than one boat, you vote will not be counted. > >Honorable mentions in the three weeks of polling were, in alphabetical >order, as follows: > >--Albin >--Allweather 26 >--Busted Flush >--Bylgia II, a 40-foot Dutch custom circumnavigator >--Californian 35 and 42 >--CHB >--Columbia, ex Where Too, custom 60 by Bill Brees >--Dory 50 >--Fales 32 Seeker >--Fleming 55 >--Gulfstar 43 and 44 >--Hatteras 48 LRC >--Hershine >--Kanter 57 >--Mainship 34 and 350 >--Modus 1500 LRC >--Monk 36 >--Odessa, custom 52 by Ben Ostlund. > >After the voting for the single one top trawler of all time is done, I'll >assemble all of this, with pictures, at Trawler World Online. Perhaps with >a ballot form so the trawler world at large can also make its selection of >the top 10 trawler of all time known. > >As far as the List goes, next December we'll pick the TWList's Trawler of >the Decade from among only the boats introduced during the 1990s. That will >be cool way to wrap up the century, n'est-ce pas? > >--Listmeister Georgs >
G
gxk@interlog.com
Sat, Jan 23, 1999 6:21 PM

Mike Fairbairn wrote, in  part:

While we're making lists, how about assembling a list of passagemakers who
have circumnavigated?  Sort of a hero's list for the rest of us.  You could
keep it posted (with a photo of their vessel) on the web site.

Mike and others--

There are so many things I'd like to do with the website but . . . time,
more than money, is in short supply.

The list of circumnavigators under power is quite short:

Ben Carlin  Half-Safe  Amphibious Jeep
Eilco Kasemier  Bylgia II  Custom 40-footer
David Scott Cowper  Mabel E. Holland  Converted 42-foot lifeboat  Two
circumnavigations
Bruce and Joan Kessler  Zopilote    Delta 70
Bryan Peterson  Sunrider  Zodiac 24
Jim and Susy Sink  Salvation II  Nordhavn 46
Jock Wishart  Cable & Wireless Adventurer  Custom 115-foot trimaran.

One could argue about about the nature of several of the above
circumnavuigations, but, what the heck, their voyages around the planet
were remarkable, regardless.

--Listmeister Georgs

Georgs Kolesnikovs
Listmeister of Trawler World Online at http://www.trawlerworld.com
To post a message to the list, address it to trawler-world-list@samurai.com
List archives are at http://www.samurai.com/lists/

Mike Fairbairn wrote, in part: >While we're making lists, how about assembling a list of passagemakers who >have circumnavigated? Sort of a hero's list for the rest of us. You could >keep it posted (with a photo of their vessel) on the web site. Mike and others-- There are so many things I'd like to do with the website but . . . time, more than money, is in short supply. The list of circumnavigators under power is quite short: Ben Carlin Half-Safe Amphibious Jeep Eilco Kasemier Bylgia II Custom 40-footer David Scott Cowper Mabel E. Holland Converted 42-foot lifeboat Two circumnavigations Bruce and Joan Kessler Zopilote Delta 70 Bryan Peterson Sunrider Zodiac 24 Jim and Susy Sink Salvation II Nordhavn 46 Jock Wishart Cable & Wireless Adventurer Custom 115-foot trimaran. One could argue about about the nature of several of the above circumnavuigations, but, what the heck, their voyages around the planet were remarkable, regardless. --Listmeister Georgs Georgs Kolesnikovs Listmeister of Trawler World Online at <http://www.trawlerworld.com> To post a message to the list, address it to <trawler-world-list@samurai.com> List archives are at <http://www.samurai.com/lists/>