passagemaking@lists.trawlering.com

Passagemaking Under Power List

View all threads

Re: [PUP] Boat quality electrical

GP
graham pugh
Mon, Nov 19, 2007 8:15 PM

Having retired from the engineering/technical field of the electronics
industry and from my limited personal experience with the various boats I've
owned
and a few boats owned by friends, I make the following observations where I
think the marine industry is sadly lacking in quality.  For example, by
comparison to the high end of the automobile industry.

  1. System documentation generally stinks, and any attempt to provide good
    flow diagrams is often missing, In particular showing interconnections
    between
    various interfaces. Generally speaking I have always been quite satisfied
    with the manuals provided from the equipment manufactures, perhaps with the
    exception
    of the lack of schematics, which they seem to think everybody would want to
    copy,
    if they provided.( If I really wanted to copy a piece of equipment I
    wouldn't
    need a schematic. )

  2. If cables were just colour coded and numbered it would  not only make it
    easier for the installer, but certainly for trouble shooting later. The idea
    of  adding an extra cable in certain locations might be a good one, but
    I would be quite satisfied with a string left in the run to be able to
    pull an extra or replacement cable through at some later date if needed.

  3. Connections & connectors, which are generally a major cause of equipment
    failures on boats should always be made with as many environmentally
    approved
    connectors as possible, where practical  hermetically sealed, using an
    approved dielectric for insulating the connections and
    connector. Edge connector contacts are rarely of the highest quality, I
    would think gold
    contacts should be mandatory in the marine industry where feasible. I have
    really been amazed to see how much
    this is lacking from reputable navigation equipment manufacturers.

YMMV

Graham Pugh

Having retired from the engineering/technical field of the electronics industry and from my limited personal experience with the various boats I've owned and a few boats owned by friends, I make the following observations where I think the marine industry is sadly lacking in quality. For example, by comparison to the high end of the automobile industry. 1. System documentation generally stinks, and any attempt to provide good flow diagrams is often missing, In particular showing interconnections between various interfaces. Generally speaking I have always been quite satisfied with the manuals provided from the equipment manufactures, perhaps with the exception of the lack of schematics, which they seem to think everybody would want to copy, if they provided.( If I really wanted to copy a piece of equipment I wouldn't need a schematic. ) 2. If cables were just colour coded and numbered it would not only make it easier for the installer, but certainly for trouble shooting later. The idea of adding an extra cable in certain locations might be a good one, but I would be quite satisfied with a string left in the run to be able to pull an extra or replacement cable through at some later date if needed. 3. Connections & connectors, which are generally a major cause of equipment failures on boats should always be made with as many environmentally approved connectors as possible, where practical hermetically sealed, using an approved dielectric for insulating the connections and connector. Edge connector contacts are rarely of the highest quality, I would think gold contacts should be mandatory in the marine industry where feasible. I have really been amazed to see how much this is lacking from reputable navigation equipment manufacturers. YMMV Graham Pugh