passagemaking@lists.trawlering.com

Passagemaking Under Power List

View all threads

Weather and Weather Routing

PP
Peter Pisciotta
Thu, Jul 5, 2007 1:36 PM

I too have read Milt Baker's travels aboard Bluewater
with keen interest. He's a great writer, and we're all
fortunate he takes so much time to really impart the
essence of passagemaking.

It's been a few years since I used a weather router
(Walt Hack, who passed away last year - also of Omni
Marine, the company Milt is using), and the cost was
indeed reasonable - about $80/leg. I used Walt on a
trip from Southern California to Port Everglades
Florida. We made 2 stops (Acapulco and Panama) so the
cost was under $250 for the trip. Not bad considering
we covered 4500 miles, received at least one email
daily, and had peace of mind.

The reason for using a weather router was the boat I
was delivering had no onboard weather capabilities
beyond an Iridium phone. Also of great help was my
friend Paul Goyette, an amateur wx prognosticator and
on/off cruiser, who also forwarded wx info - he proved
to be as accurate as Walt. It was a good time of year
to make the trip, weather was generally benign for
2/3's of the trip (headseas in the Atlantic were
uncomfortable), so it wasn't a problem.

Pesonally, I really don't like having to depend on a
weather router to interpret data for me. I'm a visual
person and while I can plot the center of a wx system,
I just can't visualize what its doing - all the
subtlties of crooks in the isobars are invisible. To
me, it feels like I'm blindfolded in a dark room with
someone telling me how to move - I can't anticipate, I
can't make a good decision given my circumstances
(crew, boat, gear, etc). Weather forecasting
capabilities are an integral part of both a boat and
the cruisers aboard (note Milt has multiple wx sources

  • he just happens to prefer using a router).
    Professional delivery captains sometimes use routers
    when moving boats during hurricane season.

I have to say, I've found no successful way to learn
wx forecasting except trial and error. Sure, books and
seminars speed the process, but until I actually had
to live with the result of my forecast, it was hard to
really learn wx.

Amongst cruisers, weather is topic #1 of discussion.
Not gear, not engines, not provisioning, not boats.
But weather. There is often a herd of cruisers in
Hualtulco Mexico awaiting a wx window to cross
Teuhentepec, and I suspect the herd waits until the
most timid cruiser says its okay to depart (and
sometimes missing the window - the bad stuff is 20
hours out of Hualtulco). By learning wx and having
some tools aboard beyond VHF (wx fax for example), the
door to exploration is opened. Its part of good
seamanship skills. Otherwise, no matter how sound your
boat is, no matter how extensive your spare parts
inventory is, your cruising itinerary will be
dependent upon someone else - usually other cruisers
who's knowledge may not be as accurate as they lead
you to believe.

Peter

I too have read Milt Baker's travels aboard Bluewater with keen interest. He's a great writer, and we're all fortunate he takes so much time to really impart the essence of passagemaking. It's been a few years since I used a weather router (Walt Hack, who passed away last year - also of Omni Marine, the company Milt is using), and the cost was indeed reasonable - about $80/leg. I used Walt on a trip from Southern California to Port Everglades Florida. We made 2 stops (Acapulco and Panama) so the cost was under $250 for the trip. Not bad considering we covered 4500 miles, received at least one email daily, and had peace of mind. The reason for using a weather router was the boat I was delivering had no onboard weather capabilities beyond an Iridium phone. Also of great help was my friend Paul Goyette, an amateur wx prognosticator and on/off cruiser, who also forwarded wx info - he proved to be as accurate as Walt. It was a good time of year to make the trip, weather was generally benign for 2/3's of the trip (headseas in the Atlantic were uncomfortable), so it wasn't a problem. Pesonally, I really don't like having to depend on a weather router to interpret data for me. I'm a visual person and while I can plot the center of a wx system, I just can't visualize what its doing - all the subtlties of crooks in the isobars are invisible. To me, it feels like I'm blindfolded in a dark room with someone telling me how to move - I can't anticipate, I can't make a good decision given my circumstances (crew, boat, gear, etc). Weather forecasting capabilities are an integral part of both a boat and the cruisers aboard (note Milt has multiple wx sources - he just happens to prefer using a router). Professional delivery captains sometimes use routers when moving boats during hurricane season. I have to say, I've found no successful way to learn wx forecasting except trial and error. Sure, books and seminars speed the process, but until I actually had to live with the result of my forecast, it was hard to really learn wx. Amongst cruisers, weather is topic #1 of discussion. Not gear, not engines, not provisioning, not boats. But weather. There is often a herd of cruisers in Hualtulco Mexico awaiting a wx window to cross Teuhentepec, and I suspect the herd waits until the most timid cruiser says its okay to depart (and sometimes missing the window - the bad stuff is 20 hours out of Hualtulco). By learning wx and having some tools aboard beyond VHF (wx fax for example), the door to exploration is opened. Its part of good seamanship skills. Otherwise, no matter how sound your boat is, no matter how extensive your spare parts inventory is, your cruising itinerary will be dependent upon someone else - usually other cruisers who's knowledge may not be as accurate as they lead you to believe. Peter