passagemaking@lists.trawlering.com

Passagemaking Under Power List

View all threads

Re: [PUP] [NordhavnDreamers] Re: Manifest unsafe voyage

JM
John Marshall
Sun, Aug 30, 2009 4:51 PM

Ron,
One of the "joys" of on-line humor, especially the dry kind without
lots of added emoticons, is that once in a while it comes across as a
slap instead of a tickle. We've all been there and done that.

I understood exactly what you were saying and chuckled at your initial
posting, given I know Peter well.  He's such an enthusiastic cruiser,
starting (as I did) with zero knowledge but now is accomplished by any
standards, so I always enjoy his posts, prickly or not.

Many long-time "mariners" look down their nose at those of us who
retire and go out and buy expensive Nordhavns with our great plans.
They snicker and wonder how long it will take to sink the boat, or if
it'll become a condo queen. But Peter is one of the folks who reminds
us that its really possible to do exactly what Nordhavn advertises and
enjoy every minute of it (well, almost).

I'm not in Peter's class, but I've gone from zero to 10,000 nm on my
N55 now, and find that I'm a lot more comfortable going to the wild
places and traveling in weather than most of the "old hands". When we
came down a large section of the "boat-eating outside passage" from
Alaska this summer (instead of the usual "inside passage"), some
people thought we were crazy. But we loved every minute of it, despite
the rocks, marginal charting, fog and sea conditions. Most especially
the fact that we rarely saw another boat (other than friends on
another Nordhavn who we'd arranged to periodically catch up with).

I've concluded that powerboat cruisers come in the following sizes:

  1. Very experienced and often traveling great distances, basically
    staying out of marinas most of the time. They are closer to cruising
    sailboaters than anything else. Old salts. Whatever. They spend very
    little or no time on the internet and email, so in general, we often
    don't hear from them unless we happen to cross their paths. Plenty of
    N46 owners in this group.

  2. Guys like Peter who buy a capable, state-of-the-art trawler yacht
    and then very deliberately learn how to operate it, maintain it, and
    use it to go remote places that are well outside the usual pattern for
    powerboats, gaining years of experience in every month of adventurous
    travel. Well connected to the internet via modern systems, so we get
    to hear from them. (A few years ago, I'm told you could determine if
    you were in one of those remote places because you were the only
    powerboat among many sailboats. But there are more powerboats showing
    up every year. Nordhavns still lead that list, but we increasingly
    find Kady's and Diesel Ducks and the occasional Selene, along with a
    smattering of custom trawler yachts.) Adventurous cruising used to be
    a young sailboater's game, and still largely is, but now a good
    trawler yacht gives us older guys a chance to play.

  3. Guys who have owned powerboats for decades and use them a few weeks
    each summer, keep them mostly in marinas, and rarely/never go to
    remote and/or difficult-to-reach places, but who have a very high
    regard for their vast years of experience and knowledge. They only go
    out when the weather is perfect and, upon getting caught in bad
    weather, run for port with a story of heroic adventure. We've
    (briefly) cruised with such types, and we just keep on going in bad
    weather while they go and hide. This group drives me absolutely
    batsh*t, because in most cases, they haven't a clue about adventurous
    cruising, but they've got LOTS of opinions based on their "many
    years", and a lack of regard for folks in category 2 above.

I've come to the conclusion that miles traveled and nights spent at
anchor are the real measure of expertise. Whether you are underway or
at anchor, no matter how good your planning, the sea and weather will
conspire to ensure that interesting stuff happens, and that will force
you to learn, and in a hurry. Days spent in a marina have either zero
or negative value (given you often wind up relying on someone else to
deal with issues). I'm of the opinion that the new owner of a trawler
yacht, who has never been on a boat before, but who really uses his or
her boat and studies every aspect of it can become a lot more
accomplished in 2 or 3 years than those "experts" who have been
boating for 30 years.

John Marshall
N55-20 Serendipity

On Aug 30, 2009, at 8:52 AM, Ron Rogers wrote

My mind missed something, Tim. I cannot understand how I sent this
email to this list when my attempt at humor should have gone to the
PUP list. PUP is the Passagemaking Under Power List and was created
by Georgs Kolesnikovs to compliment his Trawlers & Trawlering List.
Peter own an N55 in Australia and was lamenting the fact that PUP is
rather moribund. He is circumnavigating Australia in segments and
suggested that he was merely a shoe salesman (se email at bottom.)
he did so to highlight the fact that he wasnt some kind of master
mechanic/navigator. I was trying to suggest that he was a bit more
than a shoe salesman if he could invest in an N55. But his point was
that even a person with a background as a shoe salesman has had the
courage to take off voyaging.

However, the Nordhavn Dreamers List has captured peoples
imaginations better than PUP has. Of course, people voyage in all
kinds and brands of boats and PUP wants them to talk about their
voyaging experiences. It is just the vagaries of the Internet
marketplace.

Ron Rogers

From: NordhavnDreamers@yahoogroups.com

] On Behalf Of tim_morris_uk
Sent: Sunday, August 30, 2009 6:35 AM
To: NordhavnDreamers@yahoogroups.com
Subject: [NordhavnDreamers] Re: [PUP] Manifest unsafe voyage

Ron, have I missed something here? What's [PUP] etc., and where did
this thread come from, and what did peter sheppard write in the
first place?

--- In NordhavnDreamers@yahoogroups.com, "Ron Rogers"
<rcrogers6@...> wrote:

OK Peter, just how many Manolo Blahnik shoes does one have to sell

to

purchase an N55? Are there that many "Sheilas" in Oz to place your

venture

on a firm footing? I'm thinking that the heart and "sole" of your

success is

that you built a chain of shoe stores. {;*))

Ron Rogers

-----Original Message-----
From: Peter Sheppard

To cap it off as a measure of encouragement to others, I am a ladies
shoe salesman starting out with zero understanding of anything
mechanical whatsoever. I am approaching 66 yrs old, and will rack up
18,000 nm at the end of this year in a little over 2 years. Yes

I'm a

lot smarter now of course, but better off I believe than many of my
friends at home falling off their twig playing golf.

.,._
Messages in this topic (3)Reply (via web post) | Start a new topic
Messages | Files | Photos | Members
MARKETPLACE
Mom Power: Discover the community of moms doing more for their
families, for the world and for each other

Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch
format to Traditional
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe
RECENT ACTIVITY
11
New Members
2
New Files
Visit Your Group
Yahoo! Finance
It's Now Personal
Guides, news,
advice & more.
Cat Zone
on Yahoo! Groups
Join a Group
all about cats.
Hollywood kids
in the spotlight
Their moms
share secrets
.

,.,_

Ron, One of the "joys" of on-line humor, especially the dry kind without lots of added emoticons, is that once in a while it comes across as a slap instead of a tickle. We've all been there and done that. I understood exactly what you were saying and chuckled at your initial posting, given I know Peter well. He's such an enthusiastic cruiser, starting (as I did) with zero knowledge but now is accomplished by any standards, so I always enjoy his posts, prickly or not. Many long-time "mariners" look down their nose at those of us who retire and go out and buy expensive Nordhavns with our great plans. They snicker and wonder how long it will take to sink the boat, or if it'll become a condo queen. But Peter is one of the folks who reminds us that its really possible to do exactly what Nordhavn advertises and enjoy every minute of it (well, almost). I'm not in Peter's class, but I've gone from zero to 10,000 nm on my N55 now, and find that I'm a lot more comfortable going to the wild places and traveling in weather than most of the "old hands". When we came down a large section of the "boat-eating outside passage" from Alaska this summer (instead of the usual "inside passage"), some people thought we were crazy. But we loved every minute of it, despite the rocks, marginal charting, fog and sea conditions. Most especially the fact that we rarely saw another boat (other than friends on another Nordhavn who we'd arranged to periodically catch up with). I've concluded that powerboat cruisers come in the following sizes: 1) Very experienced and often traveling great distances, basically staying out of marinas most of the time. They are closer to cruising sailboaters than anything else. Old salts. Whatever. They spend very little or no time on the internet and email, so in general, we often don't hear from them unless we happen to cross their paths. Plenty of N46 owners in this group. 2) Guys like Peter who buy a capable, state-of-the-art trawler yacht and then very deliberately learn how to operate it, maintain it, and use it to go remote places that are well outside the usual pattern for powerboats, gaining years of experience in every month of adventurous travel. Well connected to the internet via modern systems, so we get to hear from them. (A few years ago, I'm told you could determine if you were in one of those remote places because you were the only powerboat among many sailboats. But there are more powerboats showing up every year. Nordhavns still lead that list, but we increasingly find Kady's and Diesel Ducks and the occasional Selene, along with a smattering of custom trawler yachts.) Adventurous cruising used to be a young sailboater's game, and still largely is, but now a good trawler yacht gives us older guys a chance to play. 3) Guys who have owned powerboats for decades and use them a few weeks each summer, keep them mostly in marinas, and rarely/never go to remote and/or difficult-to-reach places, but who have a very high regard for their vast years of experience and knowledge. They only go out when the weather is perfect and, upon getting caught in bad weather, run for port with a story of heroic adventure. We've (briefly) cruised with such types, and we just keep on going in bad weather while they go and hide. This group drives me absolutely batsh*t, because in most cases, they haven't a clue about adventurous cruising, but they've got LOTS of opinions based on their "many years", and a lack of regard for folks in category 2 above. I've come to the conclusion that miles traveled and nights spent at anchor are the real measure of expertise. Whether you are underway or at anchor, no matter how good your planning, the sea and weather will conspire to ensure that interesting stuff happens, and that will force you to learn, and in a hurry. Days spent in a marina have either zero or negative value (given you often wind up relying on someone else to deal with issues). I'm of the opinion that the new owner of a trawler yacht, who has never been on a boat before, but who really uses his or her boat and studies every aspect of it can become a lot more accomplished in 2 or 3 years than those "experts" who have been boating for 30 years. John Marshall N55-20 Serendipity On Aug 30, 2009, at 8:52 AM, Ron Rogers wrote > > My mind missed something, Tim. I cannot understand how I sent this > email to this list when my attempt at humor should have gone to the > PUP list. PUP is the Passagemaking Under Power List and was created > by Georgs Kolesnikovs to compliment his Trawlers & Trawlering List. > Peter own an N55 in Australia and was lamenting the fact that PUP is > rather moribund. He is circumnavigating Australia in segments and > suggested that he was merely a shoe salesman (se email at bottom.) > he did so to highlight the fact that he wasnt some kind of master > mechanic/navigator. I was trying to suggest that he was a bit more > than a shoe salesman if he could invest in an N55. But his point was > that even a person with a background as a shoe salesman has had the > courage to take off voyaging. > > > > However, the Nordhavn Dreamers List has captured peoples > imaginations better than PUP has. Of course, people voyage in all > kinds and brands of boats and PUP wants them to talk about their > voyaging experiences. It is just the vagaries of the Internet > marketplace. > > > > Ron Rogers > > > > From: NordhavnDreamers@yahoogroups.com [mailto:NordhavnDreamers@yahoogroups.com > ] On Behalf Of tim_morris_uk > Sent: Sunday, August 30, 2009 6:35 AM > To: NordhavnDreamers@yahoogroups.com > Subject: [NordhavnDreamers] Re: [PUP] Manifest unsafe voyage > > > > > > Ron, have I missed something here? What's [PUP] etc., and where did > this thread come from, and what did peter sheppard write in the > first place? > > --- In NordhavnDreamers@yahoogroups.com, "Ron Rogers" > <rcrogers6@...> wrote: > > > > OK Peter, just how many Manolo Blahnik shoes does one have to sell > to > > purchase an N55? Are there that many "Sheilas" in Oz to place your > venture > > on a firm footing? I'm thinking that the heart and "sole" of your > success is > > that you built a chain of shoe stores. {;*)) > > > > Ron Rogers > > > > -----Original Message----- > > From: Peter Sheppard > > > > To cap it off as a measure of encouragement to others, I am a ladies > > shoe salesman starting out with zero understanding of anything > > mechanical whatsoever. I am approaching 66 yrs old, and will rack up > > 18,000 nm at the end of this year in a little over 2 years. Yes > I'm a > > lot smarter now of course, but better off I believe than many of my > > friends at home falling off their twig playing golf. > > > > > __._,_.___ > Messages in this topic (3)Reply (via web post) | Start a new topic > Messages | Files | Photos | Members > MARKETPLACE > Mom Power: Discover the community of moms doing more for their > families, for the world and for each other > > Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required) > Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch > format to Traditional > Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe > RECENT ACTIVITY > 11 > New Members > 2 > New Files > Visit Your Group > Yahoo! Finance > It's Now Personal > Guides, news, > advice & more. > Cat Zone > on Yahoo! Groups > Join a Group > all about cats. > Hollywood kids > in the spotlight > Their moms > share secrets > . > > __,_._,___
RR
Ron Rogers
Sun, Aug 30, 2009 7:09 PM

Or there are nuts like me who like rough weather as it gets the juices
flowing. Not survival weather, just some waves with higher winds - left over
from my sailing days. There is another category: trawler owners who are
former sailors. We usually drive yards and vendors crazy because we tend to
be detail oriented and would prefer to do the work ourselves. Most of us do
that because we have always fantasized about taking our sailboats around the
world and being able to fix everything on them by ourselves.

I could not agree more, it is the quality of your experience and not the
time spent breathing salt air that makes you knowledgeable. I once sailed in
a weekend overnight race in a near gale. According to the Coast Guard, we
had 32 foot waves (with decent separation) and my boat was 27 feet long. We
had an unfortunate ("Chinese") jibe which broke my mainsail track and sent
us off toward Bermuda at 7.5 knots when we wanted to go home in the opposite
direction. Allot of learning got crammed into those 48 hours and we were
very happy to be back in our beds Sunday night instead of still at sea.

You cannot tell a book by its cover here on the waterfront. I have met some
amazing people on my dock as they gently offer advice, I have come to learn
that one is a former merchant skipper with the world under his keel and
another is a former career Coast Guard officer. Some others are not sure how
to charge a battery. So you learn from some and you help others. Getting
away from the dock is key to both experience and mental health.

I just defended Nordhavn owners against a fellow who had a chip on his
shoulder (color him jealous) because of his assumptions. So those envious
people do exist. I did not enquire about his true experience. BTW, I now
associate really rough weather with peanut butter crackers as that was all I
could eat in one very confused storm.

Ron Rogers

Or there are nuts like me who like rough weather as it gets the juices flowing. Not survival weather, just some waves with higher winds - left over from my sailing days. There is another category: trawler owners who are former sailors. We usually drive yards and vendors crazy because we tend to be detail oriented and would prefer to do the work ourselves. Most of us do that because we have always fantasized about taking our sailboats around the world and being able to fix everything on them by ourselves. I could not agree more, it is the quality of your experience and not the time spent breathing salt air that makes you knowledgeable. I once sailed in a weekend overnight race in a near gale. According to the Coast Guard, we had 32 foot waves (with decent separation) and my boat was 27 feet long. We had an unfortunate ("Chinese") jibe which broke my mainsail track and sent us off toward Bermuda at 7.5 knots when we wanted to go home in the opposite direction. Allot of learning got crammed into those 48 hours and we were very happy to be back in our beds Sunday night instead of still at sea. You cannot tell a book by its cover here on the waterfront. I have met some amazing people on my dock as they gently offer advice, I have come to learn that one is a former merchant skipper with the world under his keel and another is a former career Coast Guard officer. Some others are not sure how to charge a battery. So you learn from some and you help others. Getting away from the dock is key to both experience and mental health. I just defended Nordhavn owners against a fellow who had a chip on his shoulder (color him jealous) because of his assumptions. So those envious people do exist. I did not enquire about his true experience. BTW, I now associate really rough weather with peanut butter crackers as that was all I could eat in one very confused storm. Ron Rogers