trawlers@lists.trawlering.com

TRAWLERS & TRAWLERING LIST

View all threads

TWL: Lightning Strikes & Electrical Bonding

E
e16@telus.net
Sun, Oct 7, 2001 3:39 PM

Those who were involved in the recent discussion of whether or not to
bond hull fittings to a central plate (I believe many said yes) or to
the engine block (almost everyone said no) will be interested in an
article in the September issue of Practical Boat Owner. The author and
his wife were motor-sailing in an English inlet just north of the Thames
estuary when a major squall hit quickly, and they witnessed three
lightning strikes: they saw the first two which were very close to the
boat, but not the third which was a direct strike on the mast.

The damage was significant and in several ways, surprising, ranging from
having to replace everything at the top of the mast and the standing
rigging, much of the inside electronics and all deck electrics, the
batteries, alternator, oil plug light core, keel bolts, some chain plate
bolts, zincs, and even the prop shaft. The electronics in his 35 mm
camera and cell phone were also fried.

He makes several observations:

  1. it happens so fast there's nothing you can do;
  2. don't touch any metal when there's lightning around. His wife was
    sitting on the foredeck between two winches, and the charge arced -
    apparently right through her - but because she wasn't grounded, although
    knocked unconscious she recovered quickly and sustained no lasting
    injuries. He was unhurt, standing over the wooden tiller a "few inches
    of fresh air" from the backstay to the steel rudder head.
  3. the diesel engine had a flash mark down one side where the copper
    fuel pipes are located. His surveyor assured him that a gasoline engine
    "would have exploded".
  4. re my opening para, "I'm glad I resisted bonding all the skin
    fittings to the engine or to a single grounding plate. I'm convinced
    that had I done that we'd have lost several fittings and the ground
    plate - and frankly, that we'd have sunk".
  5. if it happens, get the boat re-surveyed very carefully to claim
    properly on insurance. The damage to the prop shaft was discovered only
    1o months later.

One more safety comment: his VHF radio and phone were both knocked out,
the latter because he kept it in a charger. As a result, he had no way
to send a distress signal. He notes that no one could possibly have seen
a flare in the weather conditions they were experiencing. A hand-held
VHF, not in a charger, could well have saved their lives had they had to
abandon a sinking vessel.

Cheers, Garrett

Those who were involved in the recent discussion of whether or not to bond hull fittings to a central plate (I believe many said yes) or to the engine block (almost everyone said no) will be interested in an article in the September issue of Practical Boat Owner. The author and his wife were motor-sailing in an English inlet just north of the Thames estuary when a major squall hit quickly, and they witnessed three lightning strikes: they saw the first two which were very close to the boat, but not the third which was a direct strike on the mast. The damage was significant and in several ways, surprising, ranging from having to replace everything at the top of the mast and the standing rigging, much of the inside electronics and all deck electrics, the batteries, alternator, oil plug light core, keel bolts, some chain plate bolts, zincs, and even the prop shaft. The electronics in his 35 mm camera and cell phone were also fried. He makes several observations: 1) it happens so fast there's nothing you can do; 2) don't touch any metal when there's lightning around. His wife was sitting on the foredeck between two winches, and the charge arced - apparently right through her - but because she wasn't grounded, although knocked unconscious she recovered quickly and sustained no lasting injuries. He was unhurt, standing over the wooden tiller a "few inches of fresh air" from the backstay to the steel rudder head. 3) the diesel engine had a flash mark down one side where the copper fuel pipes are located. His surveyor assured him that a gasoline engine "would have exploded". 4) re my opening para, "I'm glad I resisted bonding all the skin fittings to the engine or to a single grounding plate. I'm convinced that had I done that we'd have lost several fittings and the ground plate - and frankly, that we'd have sunk". 5) if it happens, get the boat re-surveyed very carefully to claim properly on insurance. The damage to the prop shaft was discovered only 1o months later. One more safety comment: his VHF radio and phone were both knocked out, the latter because he kept it in a charger. As a result, he had no way to send a distress signal. He notes that no one could possibly have seen a flare in the weather conditions they were experiencing. A hand-held VHF, not in a charger, could well have saved their lives had they had to abandon a sinking vessel. Cheers, Garrett
S
steamer@myhome.net
Sun, Oct 7, 2001 5:01 PM

Many years ago I spent summers on a fire lookout for the U.S,
Forest Service.The fire lookout was very well grounded with a
lightning rod at the peak and four copper wires about the size of
your finger running in the four directions to the ground. All metal in
the building was grounded, including the bed and wood stove.

The instructions for lightning were in a frame screwed to the fire-
finder.  A few things I remember they said are:

When strikes were expected, close all the doors and windows
because lightening follows air currents.

Disconnect the old SCR 610 radio antenna.

Stand on the little stool in the middle of the lookout opposite the
stove.  (The stool was about 12"x 18" square with 6"legs and old
glass telephone insulators screwed to the bottom of the legs.

Mark lightening strikes on the fire-finder map. After the storm has
passed report all information gathered to the ranger station.

It worked time and time again for me. Scared?  You bet.  Literally
hair raising almost every time.

I disagree that there is nothing you can do to help your survival on
a trawler.

Recognize cumulus/nimbus clouds and their potential.
Disconnect the radio's and other electronics, especially the
antennas.  Shut the doors and windows. Stay away from larger
metal objects. Try to insulate yourself and others from anything
else on the boat.(the glass stool trick).  (Standing on your spare
rolled up rubber garden hose could be one way.)  Expect gusty
winds. Recite the fire lookout's prayer....a lot of the content has to
do with bargaining with your maker on what you'll do and how you'll
change your ways if you survive.

Sandy Floe
Sea Eagle (39 CHB)
Day Island, WA

Many years ago I spent summers on a fire lookout for the U.S, Forest Service.The fire lookout was very well grounded with a lightning rod at the peak and four copper wires about the size of your finger running in the four directions to the ground. All metal in the building was grounded, including the bed and wood stove. The instructions for lightning were in a frame screwed to the fire- finder. A few things I remember they said are: When strikes were expected, close all the doors and windows because lightening follows air currents. Disconnect the old SCR 610 radio antenna. Stand on the little stool in the middle of the lookout opposite the stove. (The stool was about 12"x 18" square with 6"legs and old glass telephone insulators screwed to the bottom of the legs. Mark lightening strikes on the fire-finder map. After the storm has passed report all information gathered to the ranger station. It worked time and time again for me. Scared? You bet. Literally hair raising almost every time. I disagree that there is nothing you can do to help your survival on a trawler. Recognize cumulus/nimbus clouds and their potential. Disconnect the radio's and other electronics, especially the antennas. Shut the doors and windows. Stay away from larger metal objects. Try to insulate yourself and others from anything else on the boat.(the glass stool trick). (Standing on your spare rolled up rubber garden hose could be one way.) Expect gusty winds. Recite the fire lookout's prayer....a lot of the content has to do with bargaining with your maker on what you'll do and how you'll change your ways if you survive. Sandy Floe Sea Eagle (39 CHB) Day Island, WA
Y
yourcaptain@earthlink.net
Sun, Oct 7, 2001 11:01 PM

At 08:39 AM 10/7/01 -0700, you wrote:

Those who were involved in the recent discussion of whether or not to
bond hull fittings to a central plate (I believe many said yes) or to
the engine block (almost everyone said no) will be interested in an
article in the September issue of Practical Boat Owner. The author and
his wife were motor-sailing in an English inlet just north of the Thames
estuary when a major squall hit quickly, and they witnessed three
lightning strikes: they saw the first two which were very close to the
boat, but not the third which was a direct strike on the mast.

The damage was significant and in several ways, surprising, ranging from
having to replace everything at the top of the mast and the standing
rigging, much of the inside electronics and all deck electrics, the
batteries, alternator, oil plug light core, keel bolts, some chain plate
bolts, zincs, and even the prop shaft. The electronics in his 35 mm
camera and cell phone were also fried.

---============================
Garrett----Can you positively say the damage would have been less if
everything was grounded.......Disconnected Me.

.
Captain Al Pilvinis

"M/V Driftwood"--Prairie 47
2630 N.E. 41st Street
Lighthouse Point, Fl 33064-8064
Voice 954-941-2556 Fax 954 788-2666
Email  yourcaptain@earthlink.net
Website http://home.earthlink.net/~yourcaptain

At 08:39 AM 10/7/01 -0700, you wrote: >Those who were involved in the recent discussion of whether or not to >bond hull fittings to a central plate (I believe many said yes) or to >the engine block (almost everyone said no) will be interested in an >article in the September issue of Practical Boat Owner. The author and >his wife were motor-sailing in an English inlet just north of the Thames >estuary when a major squall hit quickly, and they witnessed three >lightning strikes: they saw the first two which were very close to the >boat, but not the third which was a direct strike on the mast. > >The damage was significant and in several ways, surprising, ranging from >having to replace everything at the top of the mast and the standing >rigging, much of the inside electronics and all deck electrics, the >batteries, alternator, oil plug light core, keel bolts, some chain plate >bolts, zincs, and even the prop shaft. The electronics in his 35 mm >camera and cell phone were also fried. ============================================================= Garrett----Can you positively say the damage would have been less if everything was grounded.......Disconnected Me. . Captain Al Pilvinis "M/V Driftwood"--Prairie 47 2630 N.E. 41st Street Lighthouse Point, Fl 33064-8064 Voice 954-941-2556 Fax 954 788-2666 Email yourcaptain@earthlink.net Website http://home.earthlink.net/~yourcaptain