great-loop@lists.trawlering.com

Cruising America's Great Loop and other inland routes

View all threads

What's the Difference - MacGregor 26 ????

G
GHNutley@aol.com
Thu, Oct 19, 2006 6:06 PM

I love you "guys".  A week or so ago I tried to ask a simple question  in
trying to compare diesel trawlers with a diesel sailboat (shoal draft and
displacement hull) with the standing rigging removed.  Yet, this  somehow turned
into a heated discussion concerning the MacGregor 26.  Whoa ... how did that
happen?  The 26' Mac is not even on my  very  long list of boats to consider.

So, I ask, again, in an attempt to redirect the conversation back onto it's
intended course.  Can we have a conversation about the possibilities of
taking a sailboat (shoal draft, diesel engine, displacement hull ... like
Catalina, Hunter, Pearson, etc.), removing all the standing rigging and treating  it
as a diesel trawler when cruising the canals of NY and Canada and the  ICW?
Huh ... can we?

Oh and for you 34' Mainship advocates ... I have looked but have been  unable
to find one without delaminated decks and an engine worth talking about
within my price range.  I appreciate those comments and continue to  look.

Greg

I love you "guys". A week or so ago I tried to ask a simple question in trying to compare diesel trawlers with a diesel sailboat (shoal draft and displacement hull) with the standing rigging removed. Yet, this somehow turned into a heated discussion concerning the MacGregor 26. Whoa ... how did that happen? The 26' Mac is not even on my very long list of boats to consider. So, I ask, again, in an attempt to redirect the conversation back onto it's intended course. Can we have a conversation about the possibilities of taking a sailboat (shoal draft, diesel engine, displacement hull ... like Catalina, Hunter, Pearson, etc.), removing all the standing rigging and treating it as a diesel trawler when cruising the canals of NY and Canada and the ICW? Huh ... can we? Oh and for you 34' Mainship advocates ... I have looked but have been unable to find one without delaminated decks and an engine worth talking about within my price range. I appreciate those comments and continue to look. Greg
M
michaelv@nothinbut.net
Thu, Oct 19, 2006 6:26 PM

Greg I don't think this is a  spin off of your original post....

Greg I don't think this is a spin off of your original post....
M
michaelv@nothinbut.net
Thu, Oct 19, 2006 6:41 PM

Sorry Greg, your correct, this is a spin off of your original post.

Sorry Greg, your correct, this is a spin off of your original post.
M
michaelv@nothinbut.net
Thu, Oct 19, 2006 7:24 PM

Here's a short article on the subject that may be of some help.

http://www.trawlersandtrawlering.com/wit/winniethepooh.html

The writer makes mention of another article publihed earlier on converting
sailboats.

Here's a short article on the subject that may be of some help. http://www.trawlersandtrawlering.com/wit/winniethepooh.html The writer makes mention of another article publihed earlier on converting sailboats.