trawlers@lists.trawlering.com

TRAWLERS & TRAWLERING LIST

View all threads

Re: TWL: extended life coolant - Distilled Water

JM
james.m.bohn@Boeing.com
Mon, Jan 21, 2002 9:14 PM

Come on folks... Let's be sensible.  Using rain water or A/C condensing
dribble, as engine coolant is nuts.  The PH or rain water can be way skewed,
usually to the acid side.  What a great thing to pour into your engine!
Either one can have dust, soot, or other airborne contaminants dissolved or
suspended within.  If you really can't afford distilled water at less than
1$/gal, just use tap water.

Maybe I'm missing something, but I've noticed this tendency towards extreme
frugality on this list, a kind of frugality that is borderline irrational.
"penny-wise, pound-foolish" is the phrase that comes to mind.  Are there
really people who, while owning a large boat, are so strapped for cash that
they can't afford a couple bucks once a year for engine coolant?

Confused,

Jim Bohn
M/V Margaret Ann
1974 Trojan 44

Come on folks... Let's be sensible. Using rain water or A/C condensing dribble, as engine coolant is nuts. The PH or rain water can be way skewed, usually to the acid side. What a great thing to pour into your engine! Either one can have dust, soot, or other airborne contaminants dissolved or suspended within. If you really can't afford distilled water at less than 1$/gal, just use tap water. Maybe I'm missing something, but I've noticed this tendency towards extreme frugality on this list, a kind of frugality that is borderline irrational. "penny-wise, pound-foolish" is the phrase that comes to mind. Are there really people who, while owning a large boat, are so strapped for cash that they can't afford a couple bucks once a year for engine coolant? Confused, Jim Bohn M/V Margaret Ann 1974 Trojan 44
S
scaramouche@tvo.org
Mon, Jan 21, 2002 11:28 PM

Are there
really people who, while owning a large boat, are so strapped for
cash that
they can't afford a couple bucks once a year for engine coolant?

Jim, you just don't get it. Some of us whom you accuse of being
over-frugal do what we do purely for enjoyment. We're having fun
doing things not by the book but by our ingenuity, our ability to
adapt whatever is available and make good - even if unconventional -
use of our environment. It's not the pennies we save but the right to
brag about what we have accomplished and to sport that look of 'the
cat that  swallowed the canary'.
Sometimes these unconventionalisms become fully acceptable in later
years. When I was young and beautiful and hanging in god's country
'Vancouver', I remember a guy telling anyone who'd listen: "I don't
change the oil in my car - I use toilet paper". He even advertised it
on the side of his van. He was of course booed and accused of being
cheap and 'borderline irrational'. Well, today that type of filter is
an industry standard and I wished I'd bought stock in the company way
then....

George of Scaramouche1, stepping off his soapbox with a Cheshire Cat
grin....

P.s: Rainwater in batteries is OK. The acids dissolved in rainwater
are quite weak, mostly carbon dioxide based, and immediately
displaced by the much stronger sulfuric acid in the battery. Trust
me, I took four years of analytical chemistry in college. <smile>

james.m.bohn@boeing.com writes: >Are there >really people who, while owning a large boat, are so strapped for >cash that >they can't afford a couple bucks once a year for engine coolant? Jim, you just don't get it. Some of us whom you accuse of being over-frugal do what we do purely for enjoyment. We're having fun doing things not by the book but by our ingenuity, our ability to adapt whatever is available and make good - even if unconventional - use of our environment. It's not the pennies we save but the right to brag about what we have accomplished and to sport that look of 'the cat that swallowed the canary'. Sometimes these unconventionalisms become fully acceptable in later years. When I was young and beautiful and hanging in god's country 'Vancouver', I remember a guy telling anyone who'd listen: "I don't change the oil in my car - I use toilet paper". He even advertised it on the side of his van. He was of course booed and accused of being cheap and 'borderline irrational'. Well, today that type of filter is an industry standard and I wished I'd bought stock in the company way then.... George of Scaramouche1, stepping off his soapbox with a Cheshire Cat grin.... P.s: Rainwater in batteries is OK. The acids dissolved in rainwater are quite weak, mostly carbon dioxide based, and immediately displaced by the much stronger sulfuric acid in the battery. Trust me, I took four years of analytical chemistry in college. <smile>