List: trawlers@lists.trawlering.com
From: Scott H.E. Welch
Re: T&T: WiFi Antenna
Tue, Sep 2, 2008 1:06 AM
"Chester Brummett" writes:
>I am still looking into an upgrade, but was not planning to spend the kind of
>money that is asked for the Wave HP.
I have been meaning to post some comments on this whole discussion.
A bit of background. First, I am in the internet and networking business, so
I have more than a passing interest in having a connection onboard (among
other things, it lets me pretend that I am at work when I'm actually on the
boat). Second, I looked at an rejected the satellite options. Wayyyyy to
expensive for my tastes. Third, there is a good WiFi provider in the area I
use my boat (http://bbxpress.net/).
In past years I have relied on a DSL connection at the dock in conjunction
with the occasional open WiFi when I happen to be in a marina, but that was
not really enough. So, this year I decided to bite the bullet and put in some
form of wireless internet.
I first researched the various WiFi solutions, and concluded three things:
1) The hardware is not cheap. $250 to several thousand for a good setup. And
the high-powered solutions are not particularly user-friendly.
2) The subscription services are not cheap. BBX is $99/month or $300/year.
4) The coverage is still pretty skimpy. 100 marinas sounds like a lot but
there's a lot of water in BC.
So I looked around at other solutions, in particular the internet-via-cell
solutions. After some research I went with a Sierra Wireless USB EVDO card
from Telus
(http://www.telusmobility.com/on/business_solutions/sierra_ac595u.shtml).
This connects via USB so it would work with the machine I use to run
Nobeltec. Cost was $299, but it's available for much less if you sign up for
a contract. For a service plan, Telus is offering a $65/month plan with
UNLIMITED data for the first three months, which is all I needed for the
summer
(http://www.telusmobility.com/on/business_solutions/connect_megabyte_rate_plan.shtml).
This means that unlike a tethered phone solution, using the data connection
does not stop you from having phone conversations.
So, for $299 plus $130, or a total cost of $429, the theory was that I should
have virtually unlimited internet, with almost total coverage in the areas I
boat (http://www.telusmobility.com/pdf/bc.pdf).
OK, you are all dying to know, how did it work out?
In a word, perfect. Setup was extremely easy (less than 5 minutes). I thought
that I might need to place the card outside, but I just plunked it on a
windowsill in the pilothouse and left it there. Connection speeds were
typically 115 to 250 KBPS, which in practice was perfectly acceptable. And
the connection was ALWAYS ON! We used it for everything: manuals, Google
Earth, checking weather, the whole nine yards. The fact that it did not
interfere with the voice calling meant that I was able to do full online
teleconferences, right from the boat, in one case anchored up in Desolation
Sound! In 6 weeks of cruising, we only spent 7 nights at dock, and in those 6
weeks we had only a single day when we did not have internet connectivity.
And best of all I used Internet Connection Sharing, hooked up an inexpensive
wireless router, and the laptops on the boat could then share the same
connection. Again, no problems at all.
To top it all off, now that I'm done boating for the season, I just cancel
the plan (which was month-to-month) and sign up again next summer when I need
it.
All in all, I am extremely satisfied with the service. I would highly, highly
recommend this as an alternative to WiFi. In the US, I see that Sprint offers
a very similar deal ($60/month for 5 GB of data and $249 for the card).
The only problem I ran into is that for completely stupid technical reasons,
it's not possible to run Internet Connection Sharing if you use a Nobeltec
radar.
No connection, etc.
Scott Welch
FirstClass Product Manager
www.firstclass.com
Those who make no mistakes rarely make anything.