List: passagemaking@lists.trawlering.com
From: DOUGLAS MACQUARRIE
Re: [PUP] Top Five Passagemakers
Sun, Oct 21, 2007 8:50 PM
many others who really
> don't know
> how they will use their boats, but want to cover as many
> contingencies as
> possible. For instance I'll share my criteria:
>
> A. Time: I wanted to leave for our journey within 1.5 to 2
> years. We have
> a 2 (now lobbying for 3) year cruising window enabled by family
> matters
> being fairly settled down. When we purchased the boat neither
> daughter was
> engaged. Both ended up getting married 3 months prior to our
> departure.
> Parents are healthy or being cared for by other siblings. This meant
> ordering or building a boat was out of the question.
>
> B. Quality: I was willing to pay more for a quality product. I
> had a
> budget of 500 to 800K and wanted to buy the least amount of boat
> that would
> do the job.
>
> C. Capability: I wanted a boat that was ocean capable enabling me to
> circumnavigate, even though I reset my goals to more of a coastal
> route (due
> to my lack of real ocean experience). My rational was a boat
> capable of
> crossing oceans would have additional engineering and safety margin
> that
> would benefit my chosen routes
>
> D. Size: I wanted two staterooms, realizing the number of times
> the guest
> stateroom would be used would be small. I was willing to have a
> single
> head, but it had to have a good shower and other facilities. I
> wanted less
> than 50 feet because of how few slips above 45 there were in the Puget
> Sound.
>
> E. Fit and Finish: My wife needed to feel "at home" in the boat,
> this left
> the Diesel Duck out because at the time they were still a bit rough.
>
> F. I wanted a fiberglass boat, single screw, diesel, wet or dry
> exhaust,
> Pilot house, a fly bridge would be nice, but not necessary, active
> stabilizers with Paravanes as backup (if ocean crossing).
>
> At the end it came down to three boats, a Nordhavn 43 a Nordhavn 40
> or a
> Krogen 44.
>
> If money hadn't been an issue I would have chosen the Krogen 44. I
> believe
> it's a nicer looking boat, is capable of doing the job and has
> superior
> living accommodations. Unfortunately I couldn't swing it at 800K.
> It would
> have been closer to 1M to completely outfit it. I found the
> Nordhavn 43 was
> squeezed so small in the engine room (to get the extra fuel range)
> that I
> couldn't move around in it. So that left the Nordhavn 40. I found a
> slightly used one for $500k and negotiated an offer, brought it to
> Seattle
> and put another 30 or 40k into it. We left in August for our 3
> year cruise.
> I'm convinced it was the right course of action. I'll know a lot
> more in a
> year or so.
>
> If I were making the decision today, I'd also consider a Selene or
> the newer
> Diesel Duck. Oh, Seahorse also makes a fiberglass trawler, I'd
> consider
> that as well.
>
> If you take some of the other issues, like timing and fit and
> finish out of
> the equation, I would likely have made a different decision.
>
> Hope that helps. Scott
>
> Scott Bulger, Alanui, N40II, Seattle WA
> _______________________________________________
> http://lists.samurai.com/mailman/listinfo/passagemaking-under-power
>
> To unsubscribe send email to
> passagemaking-under-power-request@lists.samurai.com with the word
> UNSUBSCRIBE and nothing else in the subject or body of the message.
>
> Passagemaking Under Power and PUP are trademarks of Water World
> Productions, formerly known as Trawler World Productions.